Phone: 856-429-1700
Fax: 856-429-4269


California Supreme Court Looks at Defibrillator Requirements for Businesses

California High Court Considers Whether Businesses Must Have Defibrillators

Factory floorThe retailer Target has been named as a defendant in a wrongful death lawsuit, stemming from the death of a shopper who died of a heart attack while at a Target store in California. The deceased’s family alleged that Target was negligent because, although it sold defibrillators to the public in its store, it did not have any available for use by the public. The case was originally filed in state court in California, but Target had the case removed to federal court. The federal district court found that Target had no duty to provide a defibrillator for use by shoppers, but the federal appellate court sent the case to California’s Supreme Court, concluding that there was no legal precedent either way, and asking the high court to establish a precedent.

In the California case, the mother and brother of Mary Ann Verdugo sued Target after she collapsed and died of a heart attack while at a Target store in Pico Rivera. Target officials had called 911 and paramedics attempted to revive Ms. Verdugo, but she had died before they arrived.

There are currently no statutes in California that require business owners to have Automatic External Defibrillators (AEDs) available for use by the public, or to provide persons trained in the use of such devices. The only laws governing the use or availability of AEDs on business premises govern the installation and use of businesses that choose to have them on their property, limiting liability to instances of willful, wanton or gross negligence.

Legal experts say that, in order to find such a duty, the court must conclude that it would be reasonable to expect that a shopper might have a heart attack while on the premises. Business advocates fear that a decision establishing such a duty would open the door for other types of lawsuits.

Contact Aronberg, Kouser, Snyder & Lindemann, P. A., Attorneys at Law

At Aronberg, Kouser, Snyder & Lindemann, P. A., we have more than 35 years of experience helping people in New Jersey and Pennsylvania. Contact us by e-mail or call our office at 856-429-1700 Your initial consultation is free.

Commitment | Experience | Results

Speak Your Mind


Our Practice Focus
Injured hospital patient

Personal Injury

When you have been injured because of the carelessness or negligence of another person, you want an experienced and aggressive lawyer to ensure that your rights are protected.
Doctor & patient

Medical Malpractice

When you seek medical attention, you anticipate that at a minimum your condition won’t worsen because of the carelessness or negligence of physicians, nurses or other medical personnel.
Co-workers in building lobby

Workers’ Comp

In most instances, in the aftermath of a work-related injury you have the right to seek monetary benefits under state workers’ compensation laws, so that you can recover lost wages and medical expenses.

Family Law & Divorce

We understand that family law matters can be highly emotional, and that different solutions work for different clients.

Many people have the idea that when we file a lawsuit, we are suing the person. We are not. We are suing the insurance company that the person has been paying to protect them against a loss like this. The insurance company that this person has been paying for quite some time.

  • award1
  • award2
  • award3
  • award4
  • award5